The preset's 105 companies had ROE of 10% or more in every one of the past 10 years and little debt. Of them, 27, about one in four, state both rising dividends and buybacks in their shareholder return policy and either bought back shares in the latest year or set an amount for buybacks.
Most of the supported companies set a target for the payout ratio, DOE, a progressive dividend or the total return ratio, and also bought back shares in the year or announced a cap for buybacks.
The difference shows in the money actually returned, too. The table averages the total return ratio, dividends and buybacks paid in the year divided by net income, by judgment:
| Judgment | Firms | Average | Median |
| Supported | 27 | 86% | 80% |
| Review | 10 | 94% | 97% |
| Counterevidence | 68 | 40% | 37% |
The total return ratio is a Katana custom metric: (cash dividends paid + share buybacks) ÷ net income. It uses cash-flow amounts, so it can differ from the figures companies publish. The 27 supported companies returned more than twice the share of the 68 with counterevidence. The 10 needing review also averaged a high 94%.
The five companies discussed below, with 10-year average ROE ("Avg ROE") and the total return ratio for the latest year:
| Company | Avg ROE | Total return |
| Nippon Parking | 30.4% | 87% |
| ADVANTEST | 29.4% | 40% |
| KOEI TECMO | 17.4% | 44% |
| Zenkoku Hosho | 17.3% | 84% |
| ELECOM | 16.7% | 19% |
Seven companies returned more than their profit (a ratio above 100%), while ADVANTEST (40%), KOEI TECMO HOLDINGS (44%) and ELECOM (19%) kept more than half of theirs. Companies that keep profits to reinvest at a high ROE sit alongside companies that return more than they earn, all among the supported.
Note that the five trading houses Berkshire owns were bought on the stock market, not as whole companies, and the acquisition criteria say Berkshire is not interested in suggestions about stock-market purchases. This article turns two of the points Buffett praised in the trading houses, rising dividends and buybacks, into the question.
High ROE for 10 straight years, little debt, and returns to shareholders through both rising dividends and buybacks: adding what Buffett praised in the trading houses to the kind of company Berkshire would buy outright leaves 27 Japanese companies.